When Estate Assets Are Gone Before Death: What BC Law Actually Allows

One of the most common shocks beneficiaries face is discovering that major assets are no longer in the estate by the time a will is probated. In British Columbia, the law draws a hard line between what courts can and cannot claw back.

Under the Wills, Estates and Succession Act (“WESA”), a wills variation claim generally applies only to estate assets. Estate assets are property owned by the deceased at death. If assets were transferred out before death, they are presumptively outside the estate and beyond the court’s reach. This is why the court’s analysis focuses less on fairness and more on how and why the assets left the estate.

Lifetime Gifts vs Disguised Transfers

BC courts distinguish between valid inter vivos gifts and transfers that were never truly intended as gifts.

To prove a valid gift, the recipient must establish (1) intention to gift, (2) delivery, and (3) acceptance. If any element is missing, the transfer may fail and the asset may be treated as still belonging to the estate.

Where a parent transfers property to an adult child for “convenience” or estate planning, courts often apply the presumption of resulting trust, placing the burden on the recipient to prove a true gift (see Pecore v. Pecore).

Resulting Trusts and Joint Accounts

In BC, joint ownership does not automatically mean survivorship. Courts scrutinize the surrounding evidence: banking documents, conduct, and testamentary intent. If a joint account was set up to assist with bill-paying or caregiving, the surviving joint holder may be required to return funds to the estate under a resulting trust analysis.

Undue Influence and Vulnerability Before Death

If assets were transferred when the deceased was dependent, isolated, or cognitively declining, courts may intervene. Under s. 52 WESA, once suspicious circumstances are established, the burden can shift to the transferee to prove the transaction was not the product of undue influence.

Common red flags include:

  • Transfers to caregivers;
  • Sudden changes in financial arrangements;
  • Isolation from other family members; and
  • Transfers inconsistent with prior estate plans.

Go to top